Coursera
Songwriting: Writing the Lyrics Review — What 26 Learner Opinions Reveal
Songwriting: Writing the Lyrics is the closest thing to a consensus "must-take" lyric course online, and the corpus reflects that — Pat Pattison's teaching and his signature object-writing exercise draw near-unanimous praise across Reddit, forums and blogs. The content is genuinely transformative for people who can already string a song together but struggle to make the words land. The recurring complaint is structural, not pedagogical: Coursera's peer evaluation is clunky, sometimes unfair, and gated behind a paywall that surprises auditors at the first assessment. For most learners the smart move is to audit it free, do the exercises, and ignore the certificate entirely.
Final score
from 26 analysed opinions
Published AI-researched, editor-audited
Distribution of opinions
Per-criterion scores
Four focused modules move from point of view and song form through prosody (matching lyric to music), rhyme types — perfect, family, assonance and consonance — and rhythm. The object-writing exercise is the standout that Berklee graduates like Gillian Welch credit as the single most valuable thing they took away. Reviewers repeatedly say it taught them more than books or workshops; capped only because it is lyric-focused and assumes you already make music elsewhere.
Pat Pattison is a Berklee professor of 40-plus years, author of Writing Better Lyrics and Songwriting Without Boundaries, and former teacher of John Mayer and Gillian Welch. His Coursera instructor rating is 4.8 from 184 ratings. Learners describe him as a gifted, passionate teacher whose examples make abstract ideas click — the most consistently praised element of the whole course.
Free to audit the full video curriculum; a certificate, graded assignments and peer review require paid enrollment or a Coursera Plus subscription. Reddit's consensus is that the free audit alone delivers most of the value, since you can do the exercises yourself and skip the certificate gate. Hard to beat for a Berklee-grade course.
Assignments are real lyric-writing tasks graded by peer review, which is pedagogically sound but operationally the weakest part. Multiple learners hit an upgrade wall at the first assessment, and the quality of peer feedback swings from genuinely useful to abusive or absent. The exercises themselves are excellent; the grading machinery around them is not.
The tools transfer directly to any genre — songwriters from hip-hop to country report applying object writing, rhyme families and structure to their own work. It will not teach you melody, production or an instrument, so it is one strong piece of a larger toolkit rather than a complete songwriting education.
What learners said
What people loved
6- Object writing — Pattison's sense-driven freewriting exercise — is repeatedly called the single most valuable takeaway and is hard to find taught this well anywhere else.×9
- Pat Pattison is a genuinely gifted, passionate teacher whose worked examples make abstract concepts like prosody immediately understandable.×11
- Concrete, repeatable tools — rhyme families, song form, point of view — rather than vague "find your voice" advice.×8
- The full video curriculum is free to audit, and most learners say that alone delivers the bulk of the value.×7
- Principles transfer across genres, from hip-hop to country to pop, so the lessons apply to whatever you actually write.×5
- Pairs naturally with Pattison's books (Writing Better Lyrics), with several learners using the videos to bring the text to life.×4
What frustrated learners
5- The peer-evaluation system is widely described as the worst deployment some learners have seen on Coursera — slow, inconsistent and occasionally hostile.×6
- An upgrade paywall appears at the first assessment, surprising people who assumed the whole course was free.×3
- Feedback quality depends entirely on which peers review you, ranging from helpful to abusive to nonexistent.×4
- It covers lyrics only — no melody, harmony, production or instrument instruction — so it is incomplete as a standalone songwriting course.×5
- Best suited to people who already make music; absolute beginners with no musical context may find it narrow on its own.×3
Real quotes from real users
“"It changed everything for me regarding song structure and understanding the weaknesses in my compositions."”
“"Pat focuses a lot on structure, rhyme — even how consonants contribute to rhyme — and a repeatable method for finding the right words to use. The principles apply across genres."”
“"It's the free course from Berklee — John Mayer's teacher at Berklee. It's super helpful for the fundamentals."”
“"I learned more in this course than in any of the workshops or books. This is top rated stuff!"”
“"If I could give this course more than 5 stars I would. It has revolutionized my approach."”
“"Good course, but I got to the end of the first test and was only given the option to upgrade."”
“"Great content and a talented instructor, but it has the worst deployment of peer evaluation that I have yet seen on Coursera."”
Frequently asked questions
Ready to enrol?
You read the score, the pros, the cons and the quotes. If it's still a fit, here's the link.
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. The score above was computed by AI before any commercial relationship was considered.
How we evaluated this
This review synthesizes 26 opinions collected across the public web. Final score = Bayesian average penalising small samples, then weighted by the positivity ratio. No paid placements, no hidden agenda.
- 12 from Forums
- 1 from Forums
- 2 from Blogs
- 11 from Official course platform